10 Comments
User's avatar
Doctor Hammer's avatar

Prediction: what the rabbi did wrong was start a discussion with an unforeseen and jumbled 4+ minute history lesson. :)

Expand full comment
Paula Wright's avatar

and multiple adhominems

Expand full comment
Doctor Hammer's avatar

No doubt, although personally I can often tolerate someone talking shit about me with more patience than someone who just seems to be babbling nonsense ad nauseum.

"You can run me, you can starve me, you can beat me and you can kill me. Just don't bore me." :)

Expand full comment
Anonymous Dude's avatar

You only get away with that if you're the leader of a nuclear power.

Expand full comment
Malka's avatar

Candace kept saying 'i'll show the actual context and let the listeners decide'. As a listener, I did. She lost hands down. For example she claims she mentions academic discussion with regards to Ukraine when she clearly only brought it up as an example of how to view October 7th. She came over as dishonest and the Rabbi as passionate and correct

Expand full comment
Paula Wright's avatar

My point was to show when communication broke down, not who scored points

Expand full comment
David Butler's avatar

Jews are so un-self-aware. The same people who loudly proclaim that mass immigration is OK for the West then act surprised when people take offense at the double standards. It is great for Israel to be a theocratic state and keep out people that don't fit in but that is rayciss for the goyim. The holocausts must be brought up every single time anyone criticizes Israel as if it was the only holocaust ever in history. Anyone ever heard of Armenia? Nazi genocide was the worst thing in history but Palestinian genocide not so much. Chosen people? So I guess the rest of us are not. The AIPAC bribes our politicians to care about a foreign country more than our own. And Americans are supposed to be OK with that?

Expand full comment
Paula Wright's avatar

There were more Arab Muslims in Israel before October 7th than there were Jews in Gaza. Having a Jewish state doesn't mean no immigration. The UK is a Christian country with a state religion. There are multiple Islamic states. Barclay was stating, via Sacks, that Jews are the only people NOT allowed to have a state. And, however much I disagree with him on some things, he's right on that.

The Israel you are criticising doesn't exist.

Expand full comment
Simon Laird's avatar

The UK is not allowed to keep out non-Christians or non-British people. No Western country is. “Whites have no right to live collectively as Whites with the same rights as other human beings" is a perfect description of the mainstream Left's attitude.

Expand full comment
Paula Wright's avatar

It's the main weakness of liberal democracies

Expand full comment